Museum Specimens Show How Scale Insects Will Respond To Climate Change
A few months ago, leaders of the Systematics, Evolution, and Biodiversity Section of the Entomological Society of America issued a statement in support of museum collections that house whole biological specimens, as opposed to ones that only feature high-resolution photographs and audio recordings, as some had recommended.
Now researchers from North Carolina State University have shown why such museum collections are important and how they can be used to answer questions about situations that we face today. Namely, they found that century-old insect specimens hold clues to how global climate change will affect a common insect pest that can weaken and kill trees, and the news is not good.
“Recent studies found that scale insect populations increase on oak and maple trees in warmer urban areas, which raises the possibility that these pests may also increase with global warming,” said Dr. Elsa Youngsteadt, a research associate at NC State and lead author of a paper on the work published in the journal Global Change Biology.
“More scale insects would be a problem, since scales can weaken or kill the trees they live on,” Youngsteadt said. “But cities are unique, so we wanted to know whether warming causes scale insect population explosions in rural forests, the way it does in cities.”
To address that question, Youngsteadt examined more than 300 museum specimens of red maple branches collected between 1895 and 2011 in rural areas of North Carolina, South Carolina, and Georgia. By evaluating the scale insect remains attached to each specimen, Youngsteadt estimated scale population density and compared it to the average August temperature for the year and place where the specimen was collected. Youngsteadt then compared the findings from the historical specimens with more recent data from urban Raleigh, North Carolina.
“Scale insect density in rural areas was not as high as it was in the city, but there was a common pattern,” Youngsteadt said. “Scale insects were most likely to be present on specimens collected during warm historical time periods, and scales were most abundant when temperatures were similar to modern, urban Raleigh.”
Given the shared urban and historical pattern, the researchers also predicted that scale insects would be more abundant in rural forests today than in the past, as a result of recent climate warming. To test this prediction, Youngsteadt went to 20 sites where historical specimens were collected from 1970 to 1997 and sampled their modern scale insect populations.
“Sure enough, scale abundance had increased at 16 of the 20 sites,” Youngsteadt said. “Overall, we found a total of about five times more scale insects in 2013 than on the historical specimens from the same locations. The urban and historical data are so well-aligned that we can view scale insect populations in cities as a preview of what to expect elsewhere. It also suggests that we should begin looking at cities for clues to how other insect species will respond to higher global temperatures.”
The results are consistent with other recent studies from the lab of Dr. Steve Frank, which showed that two species of scale insects infesting maple and oak benefit from urban warming. The new study suggests that these urban studies have broader relevance not just to cities but also to global warming in rural areas.
Read more at: