Commonly Used Fungicides Linked to Increased Mortality in Honey Bees
Fungicides commonly used in almond orchards can be harmful to almond growers’ primary pollinator: honey bees.
According to new lab research published this week in the Journal of Economic Entomology, the fungicide iprodione, when used alone or in combination with other common fungicides, leads to a significant reduction in the 10-day survival rate of forager honey bees (Apis mellifera) when they are exposed at rates similar to aerial spraying in the field.
“Given that these fungicides may be applied when honey bees are present in almond orchards, our findings suggest that bees may face significant danger from chemical applications even when responsibly applied,” says Juliana Rangel, Ph.D., assistant professor of apiculture in the Department of Entomology at Texas A&M University, and a co-author of the study.
Rangel and colleagues tested the effects of fungicides on honey bees via a wind-tunnel experiment, in which groups of honey bees were exposed to various dosage levels and combinations of fungicides, sprayed and carried through the wind tunnel at speeds simulating aerial crop dusting. They were then removed to separate habitats and monitored daily over a 10-day period. They tested an iprodione fungicide on its own and in combination with boscalid, pyraclostrobin, and azoxytrobin). The trials were repeated three times in September, October, and November 2015.
The results showed a significant increase in mortality rate among honey bees exposed to the fungicides compared to a control group. For instance, in two of the three trials, bees exposed to the recommended concentration of iprodione died at two to three times the rate of the unexposed bees after 10 days. The effect was even more pronounced when iprodione was combined with the other fungicides.
The exact reasons for fungicides’ negative effect on honey bees is not well understood, the researchers note, though previous research has shown that some fungicides have heightened potential to persist in residual amounts in honey bee wax in hives.
The almond industry in California alone produces about 80 percent of almonds consumed worldwide, according to the Almond Board of California, and growers rely almost entirely on managed honey bees for pollination. For its part, the Almond Board’s Honey Bee Best Management Practices recommend that growers avoid using iprodione during bloom or to apply it in late afternoon or evening, when bees and pollen are not present—a recommendation also made in the Texas A&M study. “We couldn’t agree more and have been communicating this principle to the California Almond industry for over five years,” says Carissa Sauer, APR, manager of industry communications at the Almond Board of California.
“Our results may help to encourage increased participation of growers and beekeepers in the ongoing discussions on altering spraying regimes or finding different ways to apply chemicals in such a manner that takes the biology and behavior of pollinators into account. The Almond Board’s Honey Bee Best Management Practices are a great way to get the conversation going” says Adrian Fisher II, lead author on the study and a doctoral student in Rangel’s lab at Texas A&M.
Journal of Economic Entomology